Munsif News 24×7 | Special Report: A recent intellectual debate on “Does God Exist?” between noted poet and thinker Javed Akhtar and Islamic scholar Mufti Shamail Nadvi has drawn massive attention on social media and among academic circles. The discussion brought the long-standing clash of atheism vs religion, science vs faith, and reason vs revelation back into public focus.
Table of Contents
What Was the ‘Does God Exist’ Debate About?
The debate revolved around a fundamental question that has shaped human thought for centuries — the existence of God. Both speakers presented sharply contrasting viewpoints, making the discussion intense yet largely respectful and intellectual.
Javed Akhtar’s Stand: Science Over Faith
Javed Akhtar openly stated that he does not believe in God. His arguments were rooted in scientific rationalism.
Key points raised by Javed Akhtar:
- Any belief, according to him, must be backed by scientific and material proof
- God, he argued, was a concept created when early humans failed to understand natural phenomena
- He questioned why injustice, suffering, and violence exist if God truly exists
- He claimed religion often discourages questioning and promotes blind belief
His remarks resonated strongly with secular and atheist audiences online.
Also Read: Hijab Incident Case, Complaint Filed Against Nitish Kumar and Sanjay Nishad, Hearing on January 3
Mufti Shamail Nadvi’s Response: Faith With Reason
Responding calmly, Mufti Shamail Nadvi defended the Islamic and philosophical view of God’s existence.
Key arguments by Mufti Shamail Nadvi:
- Not every truth can be proven in a laboratory
- Human consciousness, morality, and intellect themselves are beyond material proof
- The order and balance of the universe point towards a higher creator
- Belief in God gives meaning to life, ethics, and responsibility
He emphasized that Islam does not reject reason but encourages using intellect within the guidance of revelation.
Science vs Religion: Clash or Balance?
Mufti Shamail Nadvi further explained that:
- Science answers “how” things happen
- Religion answers “why” they happen
- There is no inherent conflict between the two, only imbalance in understanding
He stressed that faith in Islam is not blind belief, but a conscious decision based on reflection.
Why This Debate Matters
What made this debate stand out was the absence of personal attacks. Both speakers listened to each other, keeping the discussion thoughtful rather than aggressive.
- Youth engagement on social media increased after the debate
- Some praised Javed Akhtar’s tough questions
- Others found Mufti Shamail Nadvi’s arguments more convincing
Final Takeaway
The “Does God Exist” debate was not about winning or losing. Instead, it aimed to encourage thinking, questioning, and dialogue. Such discussions play a crucial role in promoting intellectual awareness, provided they are approached with openness rather than prejudice.
Follow MunsifNews24x7 for More.
